Reasoning Engine vs. Search Engine

Navigating the Future of Information Retrieval

10 min readFeb 23, 2024

In the vast virtual realm of the Internet, the quest for precision and personalization in information retrieval is unceasing. As digital architects and gatekeepers, search engines have long held the fort, directing data flow in response to typed inquiries. However, a new battalion is on the digital horizon — the Reasoning Engine — bringing the promise of a more nuanced and individualized user experience.

Drawing a clear distinction between reason and Search, this piece is aimed at the curious minds of tech enthusiasts, the strategic thinkers of SEO, and the visionaries of content creation. Below, we’ll explore the evolving landscape of information retrieval, the foreseen conflict between Reasoning and Search Engines, and the strategic implications for the digital frontlines.

Understanding Search Engines

To grasp the imminent rise of Reasoning Engines, it’s essential to underscore the significance of Search Engines — our trusty companions in navigating the vast expanses of the Internet.

A search engine is software designed to help users gather information from various websites throughout the Internet. Users input words or key phrases into the search engine, and the program scours through multiple databases on the Internet to compile the files, images, photos, or documents that match the keyword or phrase. It does that by having the search engine send out crawlers to fetch information that matches. The data that matches the keyword is then gathered and organized into an index to store the potential to be displayed to the user. After the indexing, the keyword matches are ranked based on the relevance of the information. After the data is ranked, it is displayed in rank order.

Functionality and Purpose in Information Retrieval

Search Engines, often hailed as the portals to the web, are the unsung heroes of instant gratification in our daily digital quests. They scurry through innumerable web pages using complex algorithms to provide seemingly the most relevant links to the user’s query. The heart of their functionality lies in keyword matching, link analysis, and numerous other ranking factors that dictate the orderliness of their search results.

History of search engines and their evolution.

The first search engine, Archie, was released in 1990. Archie was an indexing tool to search through FTP (File Transfer Protocol) archives. But Archie needed to be more extensive in how it searched for files. It was regulated to being able to identify the file's title but could not see within the file to search for keywords.

After Archie came to JumpStation, Yahoo! Search, and WebCrawler. With every new search engine that was introduced, it also introduced new features. WebCrawler is the first search engine to be able to index entire pages.

As the Internet has grown, so has the amount of data that is potentially accessible. And with the sheer amount of data that needed to be sifted through new and more efficient procedures were developed. Some of the technological advancements search engines instituted include:

  • 1995 Excite: word relationships and statistical analysis
  • 1996 Alta Vista: Natural language search queries
  • 1996 Ask Jeeves: Human-assisted search queries
  • 1998 Inkomi: Provided an early version of a PPC ad.

By 1998, many search engines existed, such as WebCrawler, Yahoo! Search Lycos, AskJeeves, etc. But 1998 also marked one of the biggest introductions into search engines, the launch of Google.

Within two years of launch, Google was processing over 500,000 queries per day. Google expanded quickly and stomped the competition. Though some search engines are still available from the 90s, most have stopped functioning or were bought out by Yahoo and Google.

Google As of Today

Google has become a worldwide powerhouse. In 2021, Google handled 91.94% of all searches in the world. Followed by Bing and Yahoo, 2.86% and 1.5%, respectively.

But there are still alternatives to Google, and in some cases, they have some benefits over Google, like DuckDuckGo for privacy and Microsoft Bing for AI tools. Other available search engines include Qwant, Brave Search, and Seekr.

The way we search for information is forever evolving. We strive to make searching easier and more efficient. Search engines started out indexing keywords or phrases and showing direct matches.

But what about the context of what you are searching for? Google introduced Hummingbird in 2013, an algorithm update that focused not on keyword searches but natural language queries, which considered the context of the Search by analyzing the meaning of words and their relationship between them. This was one of the first stepping stones to introducing reasoning engines.

SEO Implications and Optimization Strategies

SEO professionals have become adept at deciphering these algorithms, molding content, and developing digital strategies to resonate with search engines. Keyword density, backlink profiles, and site speed are just a few factors that weigh heavily on a site’s ability to ascend the ranks of Google, Bing, or Yahoo.

Exploring Reasoning Engines

A Reasoning Engine, on the other hand, is not content with mere relevance. It seeks to understand and anticipate the user’s intent, marrying the art of machine learning with logical processes to deliver a search experience that is a cut above the rest.

Definition and How They Differ from Traditional Search Engines

A Reasoning Engine is a step into the cognitive arena; it reasons why a particular information is relevant. It is distinguished from traditional search engines by its ability to engage in contextual understanding and analyze users' history, preferences, and even social and environmental factors to refine its results.

Applications in Personalized Recommendations and Complex Queries

Reasoning Engines excel in those murky waters where search engines often falter: personalized recommendations and complex queries. They can provide a list of preferred restaurants that cater to a user’s dietary preference, distance from home, ambiance, and past reviews, all in one fell (Search) swoop.

What is a reasoning engine?

A reasoning engine takes searching for information to the next level. Not only can reasoning engines search for keywords over the Internet, but they can also analyze and interpret the information that it’s given. The reasoning engine is initially programmed with rules and parameters to make inferences from the user input.

Various types of rule sets are programmed into reasoning engines, including:

  • Production Rules- Also known as condition-action rules. These rules define a condition, and if that condition is met, it executes the rule.
  • Semantic Rules- Semantic rules help specify the relationship between words or queries.
  • Inference Rules- This rule set uses deductive reasoning to make logical assumptions about data.
  • Temporal Rules- The temporal rule set defines the relationship of time of objects. A can’t happen before B happens.

These rule sets provide the framework of logic that allows reasoning engines to give informed output to whatever question is asked of it.

— — -

Interpretation of information

Reasoning and search engines rely on user input to start their query. But they interpret information very differently.

As we touched on earlier, search engines follow this structure for a search:

  • Crawling- Search engines use web crawlers or spiders, automated programs that search websites on the Internet and gather information about the pages, including titles, metadata, keywords, etc.
  • Indexing- After the crawlers have gathered the information, it is indexed. Which is when all the data is collected, sifted through, and organized in a database.
  • Ranking- Once the information is indexed, it is ranked for relevance in the user searches. Usually, in most searches, the first content that pops up is the highest ranked and the most relevant to the Search.

Reasoning engines take the user input and make logical deductions, summarize information, or solve a problem based on the preprogrammed rule set and reasoning logic.

Reasoning engines first start by acquiring information through databases and user input. The data is then structured in an easily accessible format for the engine. The reasoning engine then evaluates the given information and analyzes it against the established rule set within the system. Based on those rule sets, the reasoning engine will make inferences from the data that would establish new information or conclusions.

Another example of what sets reasoning engines apart is their ability to learn. Reasoning engines are designed to understand complex ideas and make conclusions from the given information, and as the reasoning engine receives more information, it continues to learn and adapt. With that expansion of knowledge, it is more likely to output more accurate or thoughtful responses.

Types of reasoning

Depending on the nature of the problem or task the reasoning engine is asked to execute, the reasoning engine can use various types of reasoning logic to tackle the issue at hand. Some of the kinds of reasoning logic are as follows:

  • Deductive Reasoning- Deductive reasoning follows a structured process to draw conclusions based on a predefined rule set. Deductive reasoning is critical in reasoning engines as it allows the engine to deduct new findings based on existing knowledge.
  • Inductive Reasoning- Generalizes specific sets of information and draws conclusions based on the probability of different outcomes. The reasoning engine analyzes a dataset, looking for patterns. Based on the discovered patterns, decisions are made based on the findings, and a well-educated prediction is drawn.
  • Abductive Reasoning- Abductive reasoning searches for the simplest explanation for a set of observations. Reasoning engines take in the information and look for the simplest conclusion based on the information.

These are just a few examples of the reasoning logic a reasoning engine uses to find the best possible solution to the question asked. Other reasoning logic consists of analogical, temporal, and spatial reasoning.

And reasoning engines don’t just use one type of reasoning to find the answer to a query. Reasoning engines can use any combination of logic and reasoning to deduce the best possible answer. The choice of reasoning is based on the complexity of the problem, the data set available, and the specific requirements of the query.

Reasoning engines in AI

Reasoning engines play a huge role in artificial intelligence (AI) systems by establishing logical rules for a knowledge base to derive new information or make decisions based on the information.

Reasoning engines give AI systems the base for problem-solving by defining the logical rules and inference mechanisms so the AI system can explore possible solutions, set goals, or decide. Without some reasoning logic or rule sets, AI systems would have no base to make a decision, making the data given by the AI unreliable.

Natural Language Understanding (NLU) is also crucial in AI systems. NLUs analyze the relationship of words that are inputted in the system. It can then put that language into context to fully understand what the intent of the question is rather than a keyword search similar to which a search engine functions.

NLUs are complementary to reasoning engines in the AI realm. The NLU will analyze and interpret the input and give it semantic meaning. At the same time, the reasoning engine will take that interpretation and semantic meaning and make an informed decision or interact with the user meaningfully.

Data Analysis and predictive modeling also benefit from reasoning engines. Data analysis takes raw data, compiles it, organizes it, and deduces meaningful insights. Humans can do the insights from the data analysis, but when you pair the data analysis with AI and reasoning engines, things start to speed up. With reasoning engines, the data from the analysis can infer patterns related to the data and make predictions from that historical data of what may occur.

Reasoning engines provide fundamental rules for AI systems to understand and decipher information to output a well-informed response.

Challenges and limitations

Reasoning engines are starting to sound impressive, but are there any drawbacks to them? Reasoning engines are only as good as the knowledge that it has. Reasoning engines deduce and infer information from the knowledge set and rules they have in place. Still, maintaining that information can be time-consuming, so the information given may need to be updated.

The human brain can be a very complex and illogical thing. One of the limitations of reasoning engines is capturing the spirit of the inquiry of a human. Reasoning engines interpret logical next steps or predict outcomes but don’t necessarily account for the illogical mind.

Another potential limitation of reasoning engines is incomplete data. A reasoning engine can make proper predictive analyses with a complete data set. Predictive decision-making is a powerful tool that reasoning engines possess. Still, the reasoning engine can only output well-thought-out data if the prediction is based on a reasonable amount of good data.

Comparison of Reasoning and Search Engines

Speed, Accuracy, and Relevance

In the realm of sheer speed and initial reactions, Search Engines may still hold the edge. However, the tide is turning, with Reasoning Engines rapidly catching up through iterative improvements and a sophisticated analysis of multi-layered data.

User Experience and Adaptability

Reasoning Engines boasts a user experience akin to riding the digital equivalent of a finely-tuned steed — a search that resonates with the user personally. Search Engines are structured, whereas Reasoning Engines are adaptable, often learning from the user’s interactions to refine their future performance.

Future Implications and Trends

The future portends an exciting synergy between these two engines. While Search Engines will continue to serve as the initial sifters of information, Reasoning Engines are set to step in as the companions for users seeking more profound interactions with the digital world.

Evolution of Search Technologies

The impending evolution of Search Technologies is not a zero-sum game between the two engines. It spells out an augmentation of one with the other, with Search Engines perhaps adopting Reasoning Elements to bolster relevance and personalization.

Impact on Content Strategy and SEO Practices

Content Strategy must evolve to deal with an inevitable transition to Reasoning Engines. The way forward will be less emphasis on keywords and more on in-depth content, logical context, and user engagement. SEO practices, too, must pivot to optimize not just for Search but for personalized Reasoning as well.

Are reasoning engines the future?

Reasoning engines are a giant leap forward from search engines in understanding information. Reasoning engines can be an indispensable tool if you are looking for assistance with a complex problem requiring some reasoning or predicting outcomes. But reasoning engines are still a relatively new technology, and the information should always be verified. But nothing beats a search engine if you only have a simple request for specific information.

The rise of Reasoning Engines is not a disruptive storm in the search teacup. It is a paradigm shift that implores us to rethink our digital strategies and imagine a web where the line between machine and personal assistant becomes increasingly blurred.

It is crucial for those who ride the digital wave to adapt to this change. For content creators, it means crafting narratives that resonate on a more personal level, while for SEO professionals, it’s about optimizing for the unknown — the logic of machines pieced perfectly with the nuances of human whims.




A Seattle web design and online marketing agency that delivers high-end websites. A passion for web development and SEO.